I'm going to say Jumpsteady, and here is why;

His flow is inconsistent, his voice is weak on occasion, and he never really had a gimmick - but when I heard 'Thirteenth Skull' for the first time, my eyes were opened to an entirely different story-telling method that had never occurred to me before.  At the time, I was a film maker and wrote scripts for comic books.  I just love telling stories, always have.  And so Jumpsteady made me realise that maybe I could do stories with music, too.  Flash forward 2 years later, and I am doing just that; my flow is inconsistent, my voice is weak on occasion, but I do have a gimmick.  I've always felt inspired in one way or another by everyone at Psychopathic, past and present.

But no one motivated me to try something completely new quite like Jumpsteady.  And that is why he is my favorite.

zug izland, always has been, always will be. wasnt into psy/juggalo stuff until i heard them. second fav band of all time.

i disagree with twiztid being a perfect duo i fucks with mono but i think if madrox teamed up with a better emcee twiztid would be twice as nuts

regardless tho this is a really hard question to answer for me cuz i havent really been feelin much of the music psy has been releasing blaze is the only one whose stayed consistent with me the whole time where as i havent been feelin icps shit since bpb, heartbroken was twiztids 1st release that had to grow on me & i didnt care for the cc4 tracks or the american psycho ep even abks new ep had to grow on me

so based on consistency i gotta go with blaze although classic icp is my fav psy shit & madrox is hands down the best emcee on the label. i dont really count lotus & rydas cuz those albums come every 3 to 5 years

ICP is still #1 on psy for me. I would have to say that Twiztid often seems more talented when it comes to spitting, but they've also never brought me to the same state of mind that ICP's music has. The first set of Joker's Cards, and also the sideshow EPs, are like pure nostalgia for me. It's almost weird when thinking I hadn't even known who they were until right after they released the very last album of the first six. Twiztid is good, but they're number 2 and I'm pretty sure they've accepted that fact a long time ago.

I also used to really enjoy Boondox, but he's no longer on Psychopathic, so I guess that counts for nothing.

Twiztid, ICP, Blaze, ABK in that order

I'm pretty sure Twiztid will win this discussion every time. And realistically they have won the discussion since the era of Hells Pit ended.

My points:

1. They are the best lyricists, and writers. That is why the rest of PSY looks to them to write some of their songs. (No hate)

2. Their "gimmick" has never interfered with their music. What I mean is who they portray has never blocked them into a single style or sound. It also hasn't stopped them from being able to collab with other artists that aren't quite like them. 

3. They have the largest range of styles. And do them all fairly well. Eg. Gangsta, wicked, nerdcore, rock, chopper, singing. 

4. They are genuinely funny, That goes a long way.

I like to believe that The Calm, and The Tempest were ICP trying out styles that had worked for Twiztid in their own style of course. This new deck of cards is a mash of what worked on those albums, their old albums, and what has worked for Twiztid for years. Which so far has seemed to work for them as well. It's easier listening music, invites more than just juggalos to take a listen. It also shows other artists mainstream or not that they're finally ready to put out some music that can be collab'd on. All while still trying to push the same messages.